Thursday, November 8, 2012

Reflection 8

I can't help but compare the two documentaries we've watched most recently. Although obviously two very different countries, the citizens of Egypt and Serbia had many of the same concerns and goals. With corrupt leaders, both countries fought to overthrow their tyrant and have free and fair elections. In both situations, the people rallied with a message of peace ringing throughout, and protests attracted large parts of the country. Both movements were pushed by the youth of their respective countries.

Even with so many similarities, the movements were very different. This could very much have to do with what the documentaries decided to show, but then that too would be curious.  In Serbia, Otpor! was a very well organized movement. It had a network of people with specific responsibilities, it had its own symbol, and it had specific strategies used at events (such as making the government something to laugh at). Egypt, on the other hand, seemed much less organized. It was more like a spark that ignited a large portion of the country, uniting them against the unsavory leader. Obviously there was some organization, but most of it seemed to happen through social networks. People were generally gathered at the same spot in Tahrir square, which served as a focal point for protests and the dissemination of information. 

Both movements were relatively successful, although it is difficult to compare results because the Egyptian movement was much more recent. 

I'd be interested to see a further comparison of the two movements, and see why they worked the way they worked, why it differed for each country. 

2 comments:

  1. I share your fascination with these two movements, particularly because they were made possible by a generation really close to us. It always amazes me to think that the youth in both Serbia and Egypt were the driving force for the movements that oppressed them and their parents for many years. It shows oppression can be ended by whoever sets their mind to do it. To take down an authoritative regime it takes will, passion and a want for a better life

    ReplyDelete
  2. I think both of these movements are very interesting, especially because they seem so similar but at the same time unique. It's interesting to study and observe because we can relate to not only the generation but the causes their fighting for. It's easy to look at an eighteen year old kid protesting in the street with a phone linked to twitter because you can visualize yourself in the same situation. Especially because the west champions individual freedoms as one of their most sacredly held values. As for comparing the two movements,I wonder if the documenters were focusing on different aspects of the two revolutions and if so, how does that reflect their differences.

    ReplyDelete